Ask Vir Ask Vir

Much of the educated middle class is preparing for a Modi Prime Ministership

When the history of this period of Indian politics is written, October 2013 will be remembered 

as the month when the intelligentsia and the commentariat decided that it was inevitable that Narendra Modi would become the next Prime Minister. Till October, opinions were divided and doubts were often expressed. Would the BJP win enough seats on its own? Would Modi be acceptable to allies? Wasn’t a Third Front a more likely outcome? And so on.


   But last month, the commentariat made up its mind. The doubts were laid to rest. And much of the educated middle class began preparing for a Modi Prime Ministership.


   Experience has taught us that the middle class is not always right. In fact, when it comes to Indian politics, the commentariat is frequently wrong. The example of the last General Election should still be fresh in our minds. Virtually nobody, including the pollsters, believed that the UPA would return to power with a larger majority. And, at the election before that, the re-election of AB Vajpayee’s NDA government was treated as a foregone conclusion by nearly everyone, including the BJP itself.


   And yet, none of this has prevented people from making up their minds about the inevitability of a Modi victory. This is reflected in the assessments of credit-rating agencies. Till about a month ago, a likely post-election scenario seemed to be the formation of a chaotic Third Front government, which further dampened investor sentiment. But now, global investors and institutions are coming around to the view that a BJP government led by Narendra Modi will take office.


   According to a Goldman Sachs report, there is “optimism over a possible political change led by BJP’s Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi coming to power”. Another institution, Nomura, says that it is the “possibility of positive surprises on the political front” which is responsible for the surge in the markets. In fact, brokers will tell you that one reason why the Sensex shot up during October was because foreigners believed that India would boom with the exit of Manmohan Singh and the ascension of Modi.


   It is a pretty damning commentary on a Prime Minister whose primary claim to fame was that he enjoyed the confidence of the global financial community. Now, the premise seems to be that the only chance India has of attracting foreign investment is if he is turned out of office. But investors and businessmen fell out of love with Manmohan Singh a long time ago. Why do they now regard it as inevitable that Modi will replace him? What happened to the old doubts and reservations?


   There are two components to the answer. The first is that Modi’s campaign is proving to be far more successful than the skeptics had predicted. He is attracting large crowds in North India and while he is still an old-style demagogue, all dramatic gestures and rhetorical outbursts, the public mood seems to favour demagogues. Nobody is looking for substance in his speeches or for evidence that he has the intellectual dexterity or experience to lead India in the 21st Century.


 "I’m not sure the Congress gets it. It may take comfort in the latest opinion polls which, while suggesting that the Congress will lose at least three of the four assembly elections, do not reflect any kind of national Modi wave."

   What is the point of intellectual dexterity, they ask. This is a government led by guys from Cambridge, Harvard and Oxford and look at the mess they have got us into! India needs pragmatism and direction. And Modi provides that.


   Moreover, Modi’s campaign strategists have finally got the message right. As long as their man talked about Hindu nationalism it was easy to oppose him or to build up a minority coalition against him. But Modi has found the government’s weak spot: its inability to lead. His speeches now focus less on his old divisive agenda, and take a more centrist line with an overwhelming emphasis on governance.


   The second component of the rise of Narendra Modi is the utter and complete failure of the Congress to gets its act together. When Modi was anointed the BJP’s candidate, many liberals thought: ah, now that he has declared himself, let’s see how the Congress rips him to shreds. Actually, the Congress has done nothing of the sort. Not only has Modi had a free run but the Congress has failed to project itself and its new generation of leaders as viable alternatives. Nobody knows what the Congress will do if re-elected. And soon enough, nobody will care.


   The Congress’s problem is that it is weighed down by the record and unpopularity of its own government. It is impossible to overstate the anger and the contempt with which the educated middle class regards this regime. The bitterness stems from a sense of betrayal. People feel that a government that was reelected with a larger margin and had everything going for it has let India down: first, by refusing to reform and then, by failing to govern. So great is the disappointment that the prevailing sentiment is: anything is better than this crowd.


   I’m not sure the Congress gets it. It may take comfort in the latest opinion polls which, while suggesting that the Congress will lose at least three of the four assembly elections, do not reflect any kind of national Modi wave. But it is easy for trends to turn into waves if the same conditions persist. And the danger with predictions about the inevitability of Modi’s ascent is that they are self-fulfilling. Once the conventional wisdom has it that Modi is the next Prime Minister, he begins to seem more acceptable and less of an ally-repellent.


   For the Congress, all is not lost. It still has a few months to launch an effective counter-attack. But for that offensive to succeed it will have to provide firm and decisive governance. And I’m not sure it remembers how to do that. Nearly two decades ago, somebody asked Mani Shankar Aiyar why Narasimha Rao’s government seemed paralysed. “Paralysed?” responded Aiyar. “It is not paralysed. Rigor Mortis has set in.”


   History is repeating itself all over again.



  • R 30 Nov 2013

    Whatever you, Mani and so many others say, PVNR Government functioned effectively till its death (the last significant act was making elections possible in Kashmir) and event after losing elections , rising above political considerations, by ensuring the handover of nuclear button to his successor. India lost a very talented leader because of adverse campaign by commentators rather than by paralysis in functioning.

  • Sayed Musanna 19 Nov 2013

    Yes, Congress has failed miserably on many fronts but Narender Modi is not the right alternative. He is a highly controversial figure with dubious records. His aide Amit Shah is going to do further damage to him.

    Congress should try to get its act together at the earliest and correct its mistakes. It should get rid of Manmrohan Singh who seems to be the root of every problem. Rahul Gandhi should lead from the front. Perhaps all of us including educated middle class may again vote for Congress.

  • Sambhav Jain 19 Nov 2013

    It is criminal to even talk about Congress coming, and anyone who votes for them is going to be an accomplice. We just need to ask ourselves before voting for them - By voting for them am I condoning such type of work done by them ? By voting for them am I wishing to have my country raped all over again ?? will get the answer! Namo is our saviour, and honestly if he doesn't come to power we should start thinking of asylum in another country!

  • To view all please click on More Comments below
More Comments:(5)Posted On: 15 Nov 2013 07:41 PM
Your email id will not be published.
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:
Your email id will not be published.
Friend's Name:
Friend's E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
The Message text:
This email was created by [your name] who thought you would be interested in the following Article:

A Vir Sanghvi Article Information

The Vir Sanghvi also contains hundreds of articles.

Additional Text:
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:

CommentsOther Articles

See All

Ask VirRead all

Connect with Virtwitter

@virsanghvi on
Vir Sanghvi