Ask Vir Ask Vir
banner

Will it happen here too?

Liberals all over the world have cheered the stunning reverses suffered by the Republican Party in the US mid-term elections.

And it’s not just liberals who are celebrating.

 

It’s all sensible people everywhere who have been stunned and horrified by the chaos that the Trump Presidency has caused around the world. Possibly the only place where these results have evoked disappointment is Islamabad where many commercial arrangements with the Trump family may now be re-examined.

 

   It’s easy to understand why a wave of relief has swept the world. Many of us grew up admiring America and its political system. For instance when I studied US politics at university I was taught that the American system of checks and balances was so strong that no rogue individual could change very much. Consensus or something like it was the ultimate aim of all decision making.

 

   The second Trump Presidency (much more than his first stint in the White House) has demonstrated that this is nonsense. A strong man with no commitment to the ideals that his nation was founded on can easily override all checks and balances, can turn the legislature into his poodle, can rely on the Supreme Court, terrorise the media, target minorities, enrich his fat cat pals and make a mockery of the principle of collective decision making.

 

   In India, unlike America, we have had no illusions about the strength of our system. We know that a strong leader can easily subvert the institutions of our democracy. Indira Gandhi did it. And Narendra Modi can do pretty much as he wants without worrying about consensus or democratic precedent.

 

   At least some of the euphoria among educated Indians over Trump’s reverses comes from a hopeful drawing of parallels. If the most powerful man in the world can be humbled so dramatically then what about our own leadership? Will it happen here too?

 

   The short answer is yes, it may happen but don’t read too much into the parallels between America and India. There are important differences.

 

   And yet, it is tempting to focus on the similarities. If you listened to the speeches of victorious Democratic candidates once the results were announced it was hard not to be reminded of India. When Abdul el Sayed, the 42 year old newly elected Senator from Michigan said that his opponents had demonised Islam and hoped to defeat him by provoking anti Muslim sentiment, it sounded familiar to us.

 

   When James Talarico the 37 year old Senator-elect spoke of replacing the politics of divisiveness with the politics of love, he sounded a lot like Rahul Gandhi. The 39 year old Senator Jon Ossoff complained about corruption and the rise of oligarchs who got richer while the rest of us got poorer in a speech that would have seemed relevant at an Indian parliamentary election.

 

   The complaints not only seemed familiar but there was the same sense that we have in India: it’s time for a generational change; for the old men who have ruled us for so long to make way for the future.

 

"In a multi party system like India the figures required for victory are totally different."

   For all this, some things are worth remembering. First of all, the Republicans did not lose because Trump followed socially divisive policies and preached hatred of minorities. If Americans disapproved of that sort of thing they would never have elected him to begin with.

 

   The polling evidence suggests that inflation was a powerful factor in these defeats. So was the unnecessary and interminable war with Iran which America will never win. The price of gasoline has shot up in the US mostly as a result of that war. Other inflationary pressures came from the foolish tariffs Trump levied on most of the world.

 

   Those are the factors that made the difference. And while the minorities and young people voted against Trump’s policies, his core constituency of lightly educated white people did not vote Democrat to the same extent.

 

   The parallels with Modi are limited. Inflation is not yet a dominant issue in India. There is some disquiet here over the rise of the oligarchs but it has not reached the stage where it can influence elections. We are not involved in needless wars we cannot win. And the spectacular failure of Modi’s big foreign policy bet - that he and his buddy Trump would work together to counteract China’s influence - does not seem to have registered with voters who have not minded that Trump has stripped Modi of his huggy-buddy status and has no use for India in his China strategy.

 

   And there are the personality differences. Trump is a slightly deranged figure lost in his own chaotic megalomania and baffling narcissism. Modi is shrewd, calculating and thinks of long term strategy. He sometimes appears to have lost his touch as protests against his rule have grown but even on his worst day he is smarter than Trump on his best day.

 

   For instance Trump took too long to realise how his party would be humbled at the mid-terms. In India Modi began thinking months ago about next year’s UP elections: one reason why he is fighting so hard to keep Gyanesh Kumar in place.

 

   There are two other distinguishing factors. The first is that despite Trump’s threats and reign of terror there are enough mainstream news outlets in the US that still report the truth. In India nearly all of the mainstream media is so scared of the government that it only reports Modi’s successes. The Hindi TV channels venerate him so much that you wonder if each day in the studio begins with some holy invocation to the great man. It matters because a poorly informed electorate makes poor electoral choices.

 

   And then there are the numbers. When Trump beat Kamala Harris he had 49.8 percent of the vote. Today even when Trump is one of America’s most unpopular Presidents he can still count on a hardcore of around 34-35 percent of voters. In American terms to drop to 34 percent from nearly 50 per cent is a huge decline and explains the mid-term results.

 

   But in a multi party system like India the figures required for victory are totally different. For all the talk of Modi’s popularity the BJP rarely wins more than 37-38 percent of the vote. It gets enough seats for a majority or a near majority because its votes are concentrated in a few areas (mostly Hindi belt states).

 

   So even if the BJP drops to 35 percent which is considered a losing percentage in American Presidential elections it will probably still form the government along with some allies.

 

   So, our system is very different from America’s. The percentage numbers required to form governments are much lower. Let’s assume that the BJP’s 37 percent vote share depends on the Prime Minister’s popularity which (according to opinion polls) is higher than his party’s. Even if Modi is less popular today than he was at the last General Election (which seems like a reasonable assumption) he will have to be really unpopular for the BJP’s vote share to drop to say, 30 percent at which level it may be unable to form a government.

 

   So things are easier for the BJP (with or without Gyanesh Kumar) than they are for Trump. It’s that numerical factor alone that suggests that Modi could beat anti incumbency.

 

   Unless of course things get worse over the next two years. Which they might.

 


 

Posted On: 05 Nov 2026 04:43 PM
Name:
E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
Description:
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:
 
Name:
E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
Friend's Name:
Friend's E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
 
The Message text:
Hi!,
This email was created by [your name] who thought you would be interested in the following Article:

A Vir Sanghvi Article Information
https://virsanghvi.com/Article-Details.aspx?Key=2494

The Vir Sanghvi also contains hundreds of articles.

Additional Text:
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:
 

CommentsOther Articles

See All

Ask VirRead all

Connect with Virtwitter

@virsanghvi on
twitter.com
Vir Sanghvi