Ask Vir Ask Vir
banner

Why won’t Modi sack Gyanesh?

For all the talk of Gujarati dominance no state matters more to Narendra Modi than Uttar Pradesh.

And no assembly election matters more to the BJP than the election in UP.

 

Consider the saga of the BJP’s last big climb down. It came in November 2021 around five years ago. That was when the government finally gave in to demands to repeal the controversial Farm Laws that it had passed over a year before. It had spent the year between the passage of the laws and their eventual repeal refusing to give in to a movement launched by belligerent farmers.

 

  Then, as the UP elections loomed, it took the advice of state leaders that it was best to bury the laws before they became a major election issue.

 

   From all accounts the Prime Minister was not happy to surrender to the protesters and to damage his strongman image. But the prospect of losing UP had worried him even more.

 

   Afterwards, BJP tacticians said that the surrender had been a mistake. The Farm Laws were not as major an issue as Delhi strategists had been led to believe and the BJP won UP easily.

 

   But that was not the end of the obsession with UP: with good reason. At the last parliamentary election when the BJP lost its overall majority the primary cause of the reverse was UP. The BJP’s seat share in UP went down from 62 to 33. Its vote share plummeted from 50 percent to 41 per cent. Even Narendra Modi’s own victory margin in Varanasi was slashed.

 

   While the BJP managed to form the government at the centre with the help of allies it has never quite recovered from the losses in UP which it had come to regard as its political bastion. This year, with elections in UP only a few months away it cannot risk another electoral setback. Hence the obsession with UP.

 

   With no Farm Laws-type issue (which can be handled) dominating debate and some internal polls suggesting that the UP Assembly election will be close the BJP needs all the help it can get. Will Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar’s role in the election be the X Factor that could lead to a BJP victory in UP?

 

   Well, that may explain why the government is determined to hang on to him. After all, the chaos surrounding the anti Gyanesh protests and the consistent damage that the agitation is doing to the government’s reputation, can be ended at a stroke. All Narendra Modi has to do is to nudge Gyanesh into resigning by offering him a face-saving job like Governor or Ambassador. Once that happens, life returns to normal.

 

   So why won’t Modi do that?

 

   Because he needs Gyanesh for UP?

 

"No election conducted under Gyanesh Kumar will have the stamp of legitimacy in the public mind." 

   That certainly is the only explanation that makes sense. Why else is the government willing to alienate a whole new generation of voters? Why is it willing to turn Delhi into a fortress as it did on Saturday? Why is it willing to defy the Supreme Court’s directions to not totally shut down metros and trains? Why is it willing to anger lawyers by detaining them? Why is it willing to admit to its own fear and vulnerability by using over 30000 cops and paramilitary troops to secure a small area in the centre of Delhi? Why is it sending policemen to board planes and arrest dissidents in the manner of some tinpot dictatorship?

 

   And the big one: what started as an anti Gyanesh movement has now become an anti-Modi movement. Why is it still worth it for Narendra Modi to risk so much, including his own popularity, for the sake of Gyanesh? Could it be because a defeat in UP would be an even bigger set back?

 

   If that is in fact the intention, then the government’s obsession with the UP election, may be blinding it to a larger reality. No election conducted under Gyanesh Kumar will have the stamp of legitimacy in the public mind. Even if Modi wins Yogi Adityanath another term it will be at the cost of his own personal standing and moral authority. And within the party Yogi will take the credit for the victory arguing that he pulled it off despite the unpopularity of the central government.

 

   And though the movement’s stated aim is the removal of Gyanesh it has now got to the stage where the longer Modi dilly-dallies over moving Gyanesh, the more the protesters will gain. The Cockroach Janata party was perceived as a single issue party. When the government gave in to its demand and sacked Dharmendra Pradhan the CJP was seen as having achieved its objective. The CJP leaders had a cordial meeting with ministers and urged protestors to go back home.

 

   That would have been that. But the agitation over Gyanesh’s ouster has given it a new lease of life. The show of force on Saturday proved to its supporters how frightened the government was of another CJP agitation. If Modi plays into the CJP’s hands and keeps delaying Gyanesh’s exit, its agitation will have a chance to gather more momentum creating more anti-Modi sentiment.

 

   It’s the same with the Congress. Rahul Gandhi has had a rocky ride so far. But thanks to the anti Gyanesh sentiment, he has emerged as a rallying force for the parliamentary opposition. The longer Modi gives him a reason to keep agitating the better it is for Rahul.

 

   Frankly, the best strategy for Modi is to say that he has listened to the voice of the people and to kick Gyanesh aside. The BJP might still win a free election in UP; it’s certainly a risk worth taking.

 

   But for that to happen Modi has to recognise that the public mood has changed. The old certainties are dead. The government can’t do whatever it wants any longer by relying on a benign Supreme Court and pliant governing officers in both Houses of Parliament. Even the print media are now showing more resistance to governmental firmans than before. Nobody takes the abuse on social media seriously any longer and nobody believes WhatsApp forwards.

 

   As the public mood changes people change with it. Even within Modi’s own government and party fewer and fewer people are willing to speak up for Gyanesh except for lightweights like Kiren Rijiju and has-beens like Ravi Shankar Prasad.

 

   And there is the practical factor to consider. Yes, you can turn Delhi into a fortress and get your cops to manhandle the leaders of the opposition once or twice. But are you going to rely on the para military every time there is a major protest? Can you even run a government in that manner?

 

   Narendra Modi still has an opportunity to neutralise the protests. But he has to choose: short-term shows of strength or long term stability?

 

   So far at least he doesn’t seem to have decided one way or the other.

 

 

Posted On: 10 Oct 2026 07:53 PM
Name:
E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
Description:
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:
 
Name:
E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
Friend's Name:
Friend's E-mail:
Your email id will not be published.
 
The Message text:
Hi!,
This email was created by [your name] who thought you would be interested in the following Article:

A Vir Sanghvi Article Information
https://virsanghvi.com/Article-Details.aspx?Key=2486

The Vir Sanghvi also contains hundreds of articles.

Additional Text:
Security code:
Captcha Enter the code shown above:
 

CommentsOther Articles

See All

Ask VirRead all

Connect with Virtwitter

@virsanghvi on
twitter.com
Vir Sanghvi